For her birthday, Jarod sends Miss Parker a special edition Red Notebook, with a picture of an unknown man. The team manages to find a road sign from Maine in it.
The man turns out to be a man that Catherine Parker visited every spring, and stayed at his Bed and Breakfast
The man (Ben Miller) was in love with Catherine
He shows Miss Parker the room where she stayed - untouched since she last visited
In a trunk, Miss Parker finds an enveloped marked "Rescued". Inside the envelope are documentation, birth certificates, and pictures of children